Judge puts limits on Agriculture secretary sending religious emails to USDA workforce

Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins speaks to the press outside of the White House on Aug. 20. Some USDA Employees filed a lawsuit after she sent an all-staff email celebrating Easter.

Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins speaks to the press outside of the White House on Aug. 20. Some USDA Employees filed a lawsuit after she sent an all-staff email celebrating Easter. Jim WATSON / AFP / Getty Images

USDA officials called the ruling an “unprecedented attempt to muzzle” a secretary and said they are considering an appeal.

A federal judge on Thursday wrote that Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins went “too far” in an email sent to the department’s workforce celebrating the Christian holiday of Easter in an order blocking her from sharing similar messages. 

“The secretary must recognize certain boundaries when communicating religious messages,” wrote District Judge Trina L Thompson, a Biden appointee, who pointed to USDA’s own guidance on religious expression. “She ‘[m]ust stop if a colleague asks [her] to stop,’ she ‘[c]annot create a hostile work environment through persistent unwelcome advances’ and she ‘[c]annot use official authority to pressure subordinates.’” 

Earlier this year, a group of USDA employees and the National Federation of Federal Employees filed a lawsuit after Rollins sent the Easter email. Specifically, they objected to language in the message that assumed the recipient is Christian, such as “Today we celebrate the greatest story ever told, the foundation of our faith and the abiding hope of all mankind.” 

Thompson determined that the secretary’s authority, the fact the message was sent department-wide as well as the “alienating language” all amounted to “coercive pressure” that runs afoul of the First Amendment. 

“By comparing federal employees to ‘the very first disciples to encounter our risen Lord in the Upper Room almost two thousand years ago’ and calling on those employees to carry out ‘the mission each of us has been called for’ with ‘Paschal joy,’ the secretary is portraying the agency’s work as a mission to serve her particular Christian views,” she wrote. “This is th[e] type of conduct the framers sought to protect against.” 

NFFE celebrated the decision. 

“Federal employees are public servants, not an audience for their bosses’ personal religious beliefs,” said National President Randy Erwin in a statement. “Federal employees shouldn’t feel pressured to participate in religious expression or be made to feel that their faith, or lack thereof, affects their standing in the workplace.”

USDA, on the other hand, is considering appealing the ruling. 

“This is a completely unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary; the department is evaluating all options including a prompt appeal,” a spokesperson said in a statement to Government Executive. 

Last year, the Office of Personnel Management issued guidance that explicitly permitted federal employees to seek to "persuade others of the correctness of their own religious views” in the workplace, among other religious activities. 

USDA is also pursuing a reorganization that involves relocating many employees across the country, but the initiative is currently blocked by a judge’s order.

If you have a tip that can contribute to our reporting, Sean Michael Newhouse can be reached securely at seanthenewsboy.45 on Signal.

NEXT STORY: TEFCA set to grow, update policies after DOD, VA connections