Senate Committee Votes to Protect Right to Post Negative Yelp Reviews


Featured eBooks

Digital First
What’s Next for Federal Customer Experience
Cloud Smarter

The Consumer Review Freedom Act would bar contracts that gag consumers from leaving negative online reviews.

The Sen­ate Com­merce Com­mit­tee ad­vanced le­gis­la­tion Wed­nes­day aimed at pro­tect­ing the right of con­sumers to leave neg­at­ive on­line re­views about busi­nesses.

The Con­sumer Re­view Free­dom Act, which passed the pan­el in a voice vote, would bar the use of con­trac­tu­al gag clauses that pro­hib­it con­sumers from say­ing any­thing dis­par­aging about the busi­ness, in­clud­ing in an on­line re­view.

Sen­ate Com­merce Com­mit­tee Chair­man John Thune, a South Dakota Re­pub­lic­an who sponsored the bill, ar­gued that such clauses “stifle free and hon­est speech” and “de­crease con­sumer power.”

At a hear­ing on the is­sue earli­er this month, Jen­nifer Palmer, an Ore­gon wo­man, test­i­fied that her hus­band had bought Christ­mas gifts from an on­line re­tail­er called KlearGear. After the gifts nev­er ar­rived and the com­pany didn’t re­spond to their com­plaints, Palmer left a crit­ic­al re­view of the com­pany on Ripof­fRe­

More than three years later, KlearGear con­tac­ted her, claim­ing she was in vi­ol­a­tion of a non-dis­par­age­ment clause in the com­pany’s terms of use and that she owed $3,500 un­less she re­moved the re­view. But Ripof­fRe­ doesn’t al­low con­sumers to re­move their re­views, and KlearGear re­por­ted the $3,500 as an un­paid debt to col­lec­tion agen­cies, Palmer test­i­fied.

“Com­pan­ies should not have the power to re­strict con­sumer speech or pun­ish people who cri­ti­cize them,” said Palmer, who even­tu­ally sued KlearGear and won. “Com­pan­ies should have to earn their repu­ta­tions hon­estly with good products and ser­vices, and fair deal­ing.”

The le­gis­la­tion, which cov­ers only con­tracts with con­sumers and not em­ploy­ees, has the sup­port of con­sumer-ad­vocacy groups and on­line-re­view web­sites like Tri­pAd­visor and Yelp.

Laurent Cren­shaw, the head of pub­lic policy for Yelp, said his com­pany is “very pleased” that the Sen­ate is ad­van­cing le­gis­la­tion to pro­tect the abil­ity of con­sumers to cri­ti­cize com­pan­ies.

“On­line re­views help to em­power con­sumers and provide feed­back to busi­ness own­ers; we at Yelp hope that this bill con­tin­ues to move quickly to­wards be­com­ing the law of the land,” he said in an emailed state­ment.

The bill, which is co­sponsored by Sens. Bri­an Schatz and Jerry Mor­an, now heads to the Sen­ate floor for con­sid­er­a­tion. Rep. Dar­rell Issa, a Cali­for­nia Re­pub­lic­an, has in­tro­duced coun­ter­part le­gis­la­tion in the House, but it’s yet to re­ceive a vote in com­mit­tee.

(Image via GongTo/